Gage & Tollner Reservations

About the restaurant

Gage & Tollner, a historic gem nestled in the heart of Downtown Brooklyn, is a stunning revival of one of New York City’s oldest and most storied restaurants. Originally opened in 1879, this iconic chop house has been meticulously restored to its former Gilded Age glory, complete with gas-lit chandeliers, rich mahogany paneling, and plush velvet banquettes. The vintage charm and old-world elegance of Gage & Tollner transport diners back in time, offering a unique dining experience that blends the past with a contemporary twist.

The menu at Gage & Tollner is a modern take on classic American fare, drawing inspiration from the restaurant’s rich history while incorporating fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Signature dishes include the Baked Clams with breadcrumbs and herbs, the Parker House Rolls that are warm and buttery perfection, and the legendary She-Crab Soup, a creamy, delicate bisque that has been a beloved staple since the restaurant’s early days. For mains, the selection of steaks and chops, such as the Porterhouse for Two and the Lamb Saddle Chop, are cooked to perfection and served with a variety of sauces and sides that elevate the classic steakhouse experience.

Seafood lovers will appreciate dishes like the Oysters Rockefeller and the Lobster Newburg, nods to the restaurant’s 19th-century roots, but updated with modern flair. The menu also features lighter fare, including the elegant Crab Louie Salad and a selection of expertly crafted vegetable sides, ensuring there’s something to please every palate.

Complementing the cuisine is a curated beverage program that boasts an extensive list of classic cocktails, fine wines, and artisanal spirits. The bar at Gage & Tollner offers a mix of timeless drinks like the Martini and the Manhattan, as well as inventive cocktails that pay homage to the restaurant’s historic past.

Service at Gage & Tollner is gracious and attentive, with a team dedicated to creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere that matches the grandeur of the setting. The staff’s deep knowledge of the menu and its history adds to the overall experience, making each visit feel like a special occasion.

Gage & Tollner is more than just a restaurant; it’s a living piece of New York history brought back to life. With its combination of exquisite cuisine, historic charm, and impeccable service, it’s a must-visit destination for those looking to step back in time and enjoy a truly iconic dining experience in Brooklyn.

Reviews (0)